How to show top-rated products first in your Shopify store

Updated October 15, 2026

Your review app knows which products customers love, but your collections don't use it: Shopify can't sort or filter by rating out of the box. This guide combines MDTagPilot and MDPositions, two apps by the same publisher, to build a Top rated collection and put well-rated products first everywhere else.

Rulereviews.rating ≥ 4.5 AND reviews.rating_count ≥ 10→top-rated

Step 1: tag top-rated products with MDTagPilot

Create a rule with the tag top-rated, the conditions reviews.rating ≥ 4.5 and reviews.rating_count ≥ 10, and the AND logic. Then create an automated collection in Shopify with Product tag is equal to top-rated. See our guide on tagging top-rated products for the details.

Step 2: sort the Top rated collection with MDPositions

In MDPositions, create a sort for this collection:

  • Metafield reviews.rating, Descending, weight 7: the best-rated products first.
  • Recent Sales, weight 5: between equal ratings, the product that sells more comes first.
  • Stock Availability, weight 3: out-of-stock products go to the bottom.

Step 3: give top-rated products a boost in every collection

In the sort that covers your other collections, add Tag Match on top-rated with a moderate weight, for example 4. Well-rated products with enough reviews move up a little, without overriding sales and stock. The tag and the order then follow your reviews on their own.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need both apps?

No. MDTagPilot alone builds the Top rated collection, and MDPositions alone can sort any collection by rating. Together, the tag selects products with a good rating and enough reviews, and the sort decides the order.

Which review apps work?

Any app that fills the standard reviews.rating and reviews.rating_count metafields: Judge.me, Loox (reviews published since January 11, 2026, older ones on request to Loox support) and Yotpo on its paid plans.

Which plans do I need?

MDTagPilot Pro for metafield conditions, and MDPositions Starter or higher for the Metafield and Tag Match criteria.

Related guides